Optimal. Leaf size=231 \[ \frac {\left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) x \sqrt {a+b x^2}}{128 b^3}+\frac {d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2}}{192 b^3}+\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {a \left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) \tanh ^{-1}\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a+b x^2}}\right )}{128 b^{7/2}} \]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Rubi [A]
time = 0.12, antiderivative size = 231, normalized size of antiderivative = 1.00, number of steps
used = 6, number of rules used = 6, integrand size = 21, \(\frac {\text {number of rules}}{\text {integrand size}}\) = 0.286, Rules used = {427, 542, 396,
201, 223, 212} \begin {gather*} \frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (15 a^2 d^2-52 a b c d+72 b^2 c^2\right )}{192 b^3}+\frac {x \sqrt {a+b x^2} \left (-5 a^3 d^3+24 a^2 b c d^2-48 a b^2 c^2 d+64 b^3 c^3\right )}{128 b^3}+\frac {a \left (-5 a^3 d^3+24 a^2 b c d^2-48 a b^2 c^2 d+64 b^3 c^3\right ) \tanh ^{-1}\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a+b x^2}}\right )}{128 b^{7/2}}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right ) (12 b c-5 a d)}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b} \end {gather*}
Antiderivative was successfully verified.
[In]
[Out]
Rule 201
Rule 212
Rule 223
Rule 396
Rule 427
Rule 542
Rubi steps
\begin {align*} \int \sqrt {a+b x^2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^3 \, dx &=\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {\int \sqrt {a+b x^2} \left (c+d x^2\right ) \left (c (8 b c-a d)+d (12 b c-5 a d) x^2\right ) \, dx}{8 b}\\ &=\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {\int \sqrt {a+b x^2} \left (c \left (48 b^2 c^2-18 a b c d+5 a^2 d^2\right )+d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x^2\right ) \, dx}{48 b^2}\\ &=\frac {d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2}}{192 b^3}+\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {\left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) \int \sqrt {a+b x^2} \, dx}{64 b^3}\\ &=\frac {\left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) x \sqrt {a+b x^2}}{128 b^3}+\frac {d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2}}{192 b^3}+\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {\left (a \left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right )\right ) \int \frac {1}{\sqrt {a+b x^2}} \, dx}{128 b^3}\\ &=\frac {\left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) x \sqrt {a+b x^2}}{128 b^3}+\frac {d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2}}{192 b^3}+\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {\left (a \left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right )\right ) \text {Subst}\left (\int \frac {1}{1-b x^2} \, dx,x,\frac {x}{\sqrt {a+b x^2}}\right )}{128 b^3}\\ &=\frac {\left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) x \sqrt {a+b x^2}}{128 b^3}+\frac {d \left (72 b^2 c^2-52 a b c d+15 a^2 d^2\right ) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2}}{192 b^3}+\frac {d (12 b c-5 a d) x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )}{48 b^2}+\frac {d x \left (a+b x^2\right )^{3/2} \left (c+d x^2\right )^2}{8 b}+\frac {a \left (64 b^3 c^3-48 a b^2 c^2 d+24 a^2 b c d^2-5 a^3 d^3\right ) \tanh ^{-1}\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a+b x^2}}\right )}{128 b^{7/2}}\\ \end {align*}
________________________________________________________________________________________
Mathematica [A]
time = 0.25, size = 180, normalized size = 0.78 \begin {gather*} \frac {\sqrt {b} x \sqrt {a+b x^2} \left (15 a^3 d^3-2 a^2 b d^2 \left (36 c+5 d x^2\right )+8 a b^2 d \left (18 c^2+6 c d x^2+d^2 x^4\right )+48 b^3 \left (4 c^3+6 c^2 d x^2+4 c d^2 x^4+d^3 x^6\right )\right )+3 a \left (-64 b^3 c^3+48 a b^2 c^2 d-24 a^2 b c d^2+5 a^3 d^3\right ) \log \left (-\sqrt {b} x+\sqrt {a+b x^2}\right )}{384 b^{7/2}} \end {gather*}
Antiderivative was successfully verified.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Maple [A]
time = 0.07, size = 300, normalized size = 1.30
method | result | size |
risch | \(\frac {x \left (48 b^{3} d^{3} x^{6}+8 a \,b^{2} d^{3} x^{4}+192 b^{3} c \,d^{2} x^{4}-10 a^{2} b \,d^{3} x^{2}+48 a \,b^{2} c \,d^{2} x^{2}+288 b^{3} c^{2} d \,x^{2}+15 a^{3} d^{3}-72 a^{2} b c \,d^{2}+144 a \,b^{2} c^{2} d +192 b^{3} c^{3}\right ) \sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}}{384 b^{3}}-\frac {5 a^{4} \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right ) d^{3}}{128 b^{\frac {7}{2}}}+\frac {3 a^{3} \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right ) c \,d^{2}}{16 b^{\frac {5}{2}}}-\frac {3 a^{2} \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right ) c^{2} d}{8 b^{\frac {3}{2}}}+\frac {a \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right ) c^{3}}{2 \sqrt {b}}\) | \(234\) |
default | \(d^{3} \left (\frac {x^{5} \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{8 b}-\frac {5 a \left (\frac {x^{3} \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{6 b}-\frac {a \left (\frac {x \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{4 b}-\frac {a \left (\frac {x \sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}}{2}+\frac {a \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right )}{2 \sqrt {b}}\right )}{4 b}\right )}{2 b}\right )}{8 b}\right )+3 c \,d^{2} \left (\frac {x^{3} \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{6 b}-\frac {a \left (\frac {x \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{4 b}-\frac {a \left (\frac {x \sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}}{2}+\frac {a \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right )}{2 \sqrt {b}}\right )}{4 b}\right )}{2 b}\right )+3 c^{2} d \left (\frac {x \left (b \,x^{2}+a \right )^{\frac {3}{2}}}{4 b}-\frac {a \left (\frac {x \sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}}{2}+\frac {a \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right )}{2 \sqrt {b}}\right )}{4 b}\right )+c^{3} \left (\frac {x \sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}}{2}+\frac {a \ln \left (x \sqrt {b}+\sqrt {b \,x^{2}+a}\right )}{2 \sqrt {b}}\right )\) | \(300\) |
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Maxima [A]
time = 0.30, size = 281, normalized size = 1.22 \begin {gather*} \frac {{\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} d^{3} x^{5}}{8 \, b} + \frac {{\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} c d^{2} x^{3}}{2 \, b} - \frac {5 \, {\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} a d^{3} x^{3}}{48 \, b^{2}} + \frac {1}{2} \, \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} c^{3} x + \frac {3 \, {\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} c^{2} d x}{4 \, b} - \frac {3 \, \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} a c^{2} d x}{8 \, b} - \frac {3 \, {\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} a c d^{2} x}{8 \, b^{2}} + \frac {3 \, \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} a^{2} c d^{2} x}{16 \, b^{2}} + \frac {5 \, {\left (b x^{2} + a\right )}^{\frac {3}{2}} a^{2} d^{3} x}{64 \, b^{3}} - \frac {5 \, \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} a^{3} d^{3} x}{128 \, b^{3}} + \frac {a c^{3} \operatorname {arsinh}\left (\frac {b x}{\sqrt {a b}}\right )}{2 \, \sqrt {b}} - \frac {3 \, a^{2} c^{2} d \operatorname {arsinh}\left (\frac {b x}{\sqrt {a b}}\right )}{8 \, b^{\frac {3}{2}}} + \frac {3 \, a^{3} c d^{2} \operatorname {arsinh}\left (\frac {b x}{\sqrt {a b}}\right )}{16 \, b^{\frac {5}{2}}} - \frac {5 \, a^{4} d^{3} \operatorname {arsinh}\left (\frac {b x}{\sqrt {a b}}\right )}{128 \, b^{\frac {7}{2}}} \end {gather*}
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Fricas [A]
time = 2.27, size = 398, normalized size = 1.72 \begin {gather*} \left [-\frac {3 \, {\left (64 \, a b^{3} c^{3} - 48 \, a^{2} b^{2} c^{2} d + 24 \, a^{3} b c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{4} d^{3}\right )} \sqrt {b} \log \left (-2 \, b x^{2} + 2 \, \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} \sqrt {b} x - a\right ) - 2 \, {\left (48 \, b^{4} d^{3} x^{7} + 8 \, {\left (24 \, b^{4} c d^{2} + a b^{3} d^{3}\right )} x^{5} + 2 \, {\left (144 \, b^{4} c^{2} d + 24 \, a b^{3} c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{2} b^{2} d^{3}\right )} x^{3} + 3 \, {\left (64 \, b^{4} c^{3} + 48 \, a b^{3} c^{2} d - 24 \, a^{2} b^{2} c d^{2} + 5 \, a^{3} b d^{3}\right )} x\right )} \sqrt {b x^{2} + a}}{768 \, b^{4}}, -\frac {3 \, {\left (64 \, a b^{3} c^{3} - 48 \, a^{2} b^{2} c^{2} d + 24 \, a^{3} b c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{4} d^{3}\right )} \sqrt {-b} \arctan \left (\frac {\sqrt {-b} x}{\sqrt {b x^{2} + a}}\right ) - {\left (48 \, b^{4} d^{3} x^{7} + 8 \, {\left (24 \, b^{4} c d^{2} + a b^{3} d^{3}\right )} x^{5} + 2 \, {\left (144 \, b^{4} c^{2} d + 24 \, a b^{3} c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{2} b^{2} d^{3}\right )} x^{3} + 3 \, {\left (64 \, b^{4} c^{3} + 48 \, a b^{3} c^{2} d - 24 \, a^{2} b^{2} c d^{2} + 5 \, a^{3} b d^{3}\right )} x\right )} \sqrt {b x^{2} + a}}{384 \, b^{4}}\right ] \end {gather*}
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Sympy [B] Leaf count of result is larger than twice the leaf count of optimal. 484 vs.
\(2 (233) = 466\).
time = 28.78, size = 484, normalized size = 2.10 \begin {gather*} \frac {5 a^{\frac {7}{2}} d^{3} x}{128 b^{3} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} - \frac {3 a^{\frac {5}{2}} c d^{2} x}{16 b^{2} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {5 a^{\frac {5}{2}} d^{3} x^{3}}{384 b^{2} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {3 a^{\frac {3}{2}} c^{2} d x}{8 b \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} - \frac {a^{\frac {3}{2}} c d^{2} x^{3}}{16 b \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} - \frac {a^{\frac {3}{2}} d^{3} x^{5}}{192 b \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {\sqrt {a} c^{3} x \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}}{2} + \frac {9 \sqrt {a} c^{2} d x^{3}}{8 \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {5 \sqrt {a} c d^{2} x^{5}}{8 \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {7 \sqrt {a} d^{3} x^{7}}{48 \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} - \frac {5 a^{4} d^{3} \operatorname {asinh}{\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a}} \right )}}{128 b^{\frac {7}{2}}} + \frac {3 a^{3} c d^{2} \operatorname {asinh}{\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a}} \right )}}{16 b^{\frac {5}{2}}} - \frac {3 a^{2} c^{2} d \operatorname {asinh}{\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a}} \right )}}{8 b^{\frac {3}{2}}} + \frac {a c^{3} \operatorname {asinh}{\left (\frac {\sqrt {b} x}{\sqrt {a}} \right )}}{2 \sqrt {b}} + \frac {3 b c^{2} d x^{5}}{4 \sqrt {a} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {b c d^{2} x^{7}}{2 \sqrt {a} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} + \frac {b d^{3} x^{9}}{8 \sqrt {a} \sqrt {1 + \frac {b x^{2}}{a}}} \end {gather*}
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Giac [A]
time = 0.96, size = 201, normalized size = 0.87 \begin {gather*} \frac {1}{384} \, {\left (2 \, {\left (4 \, {\left (6 \, d^{3} x^{2} + \frac {24 \, b^{6} c d^{2} + a b^{5} d^{3}}{b^{6}}\right )} x^{2} + \frac {144 \, b^{6} c^{2} d + 24 \, a b^{5} c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{2} b^{4} d^{3}}{b^{6}}\right )} x^{2} + \frac {3 \, {\left (64 \, b^{6} c^{3} + 48 \, a b^{5} c^{2} d - 24 \, a^{2} b^{4} c d^{2} + 5 \, a^{3} b^{3} d^{3}\right )}}{b^{6}}\right )} \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} x - \frac {{\left (64 \, a b^{3} c^{3} - 48 \, a^{2} b^{2} c^{2} d + 24 \, a^{3} b c d^{2} - 5 \, a^{4} d^{3}\right )} \log \left ({\left | -\sqrt {b} x + \sqrt {b x^{2} + a} \right |}\right )}{128 \, b^{\frac {7}{2}}} \end {gather*}
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________
Mupad [F]
time = 0.00, size = -1, normalized size = -0.00 \begin {gather*} \int \sqrt {b\,x^2+a}\,{\left (d\,x^2+c\right )}^3 \,d x \end {gather*}
Verification of antiderivative is not currently implemented for this CAS.
[In]
[Out]
________________________________________________________________________________________